Note: This is a research note supplementing the book Unscarcity, now available for purchase. These notes expand on concepts from the main text. Start here or get the book.
What Matter Really Is: Lessons from Particle Physics
Summary: The author of Chapter 7 spent seven years at CERN watching particles that existed for trillionths of a second. What he learned: the closer you look at “stuff,” the less solid it becomes. Quarks can’t exist alone. Particles are excitations in fields. Mass comes from interaction, not substance. At the deepest level, matter dissolves into patterns and relationships.
The CERN Experience
“Thirty years ago, as a summer intern at CERN, I stood in the L3 detector hall, watching a detector heavier than the Eiffel Tower prepare to annihilate electrons and anti-electrons at 0.999999999 the speed of light.”
The Large Electron-Positron Collider (LEP), and later the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), smash particles together at extreme energies. What emerges are fragments so fundamental they mock the very concept of “substance.”
For seven years - Master’s thesis through Ph.D. - the author watched:
- Particles that existed for less than 10^-23 seconds
- Quarks that can never be isolated
- Mass emerging from massless components
- “Things” that behave more like events than objects
You Can’t Grab a Quark
Protons and neutrons - the “stuff” of atomic nuclei - are made of quarks. But here’s the strange part: you can’t isolate a quark.
Color Confinement
Quarks carry “color charge” (nothing to do with actual color - it’s just a label). The strong force between quarks behaves unlike any other force: it gets stronger with distance.
Imagine a rubber band connecting two quarks. Pull them apart, and the band stretches, storing more energy. At some point, there’s enough energy in the band to create new quarks from the vacuum. You end up with two pairs of quarks instead of two separate quarks.
You can never have a single quark. The act of separation creates new partners. Isolation is impossible.
What This Means
The fundamental building blocks of matter cannot exist independently. They’re inherently relational. A quark alone is not just hard to find - it’s physically meaningless.
Particles Are Field Excitations
Quantum Field Theory (QFT), our best description of particle physics, doesn’t describe particles as little balls. It describes fields - continuous entities spread through all of space.
The Field Analogy
Imagine the ocean. Waves aren’t “things” moving through water - they’re patterns of water motion. The wave is a temporary excitation of the underlying medium.
Similarly, an electron isn’t a little ball traveling through space. It’s a localized excitation of the electron field - a wave-like pattern that propagates.
No Permanent Things
Particles can be created and destroyed. An electron and positron can annihilate into photons. The photons can create new particle-antiparticle pairs. What’s conserved is energy, momentum, charge - not “stuff.”
The underlying fields are permanent. The particles are temporary patterns in those fields.
Mass From Nothing
Where does mass come from? Surprisingly, not from massive building blocks.
The Higgs Mechanism
Quarks and electrons get their mass by interacting with the Higgs field. Without this interaction, they’d be massless, moving at the speed of light.
But here’s the kicker: quark masses account for only about 1% of a proton’s mass. The other 99%? It comes from the energy of quarks moving around and the strong force field between them.
E = mc²
Einstein’s famous equation tells us energy and mass are equivalent. The proton’s mass is mostly the energy of its internal dynamics, converted to mass via E = mc².
The “stuff” you’re made of is mostly activity, not substance. You are a pattern of energy, structured into stability.
The Vacuum Isn’t Empty
Empty space isn’t empty. The quantum vacuum seethes with activity.
Virtual Particles
Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle allows energy conservation to be temporarily violated. “Virtual particles” constantly pop into and out of existence, too briefly to be directly observed but with measurable effects.
Vacuum Energy
The quantum vacuum has energy. This isn’t metaphor - it produces measurable forces like the Casimir effect, where two plates placed very close together in a vacuum feel an attractive force.
Empty space is actually the busiest place in the universe.
The Disappearing Substance
As physics has progressed, “substance” has progressively dissolved:
| Era | “Substance” | What Actually Exists |
|---|---|---|
| Ancient | Earth, Water, Air, Fire | Elements |
| 19th century | Atoms | Protons, Neutrons, Electrons |
| Early 20th | Protons, Neutrons, Electrons | Quarks, Leptons, Force Carriers |
| Late 20th | Particles | Field Excitations |
| Current | Fields | Information? Relationships? |
Each deeper look reveals that what seemed solid was actually pattern. The question “what is stuff ultimately made of?” may have no final answer - or the answer may be “nothing” or “relationships” or “information.”
John Wheeler’s Vision
Physicist John Wheeler, who coined the term “black hole” and trained Richard Feynman, proposed “it from bit”:
“Every physical quantity, every it, derives its ultimate significance from bits, binary yes-or-no indications.”
In this view, physics isn’t about stuff - it’s about information. The universe is a vast pattern of yeses and noes, and what we call matter is how that pattern presents to conscious observers.
Implications for Reality
Substance Is Relative
There’s no rock-bottom level of “stuff.” Each apparent substance reduces to patterns in something deeper. This could continue indefinitely, or bottom out in pure mathematics, information, or something we can’t conceive.
Relationships Are Primary
Quarks need each other. Particles are field interactions. Mass comes from energy of motion. At every level, relations seem more fundamental than things.
Stability, Not Solidity
Your body persists not because it’s made of enduring stuff, but because its patterns are stable. You’re a standing wave, not a sculpture.
The Observer Participates
As quantum mechanics reveals, observation isn’t passive. Measurement affects outcomes. The universe isn’t a collection of pre-existing things being discovered, but a process in which observers participate.
The Connection to Consciousness
If matter dissolves into pattern and relationship, what remains? Some speculate: consciousness.
The Hard Problem
Philosopher David Chalmers asks: why is there subjective experience? You could explain all the physical correlates of consciousness without explaining why it feels like something to be you.
If physical reality is fundamentally informational or relational, and consciousness is the one thing we can’t explain in those terms, perhaps the relationship is inverted: consciousness might be more fundamental than matter, not less.
The Mystic Agreement
As Chapter 7 notes, the particle physicist and the Catholic grandmother arrived at similar conclusions through opposite paths. The mystics always said matter was less real than spirit. The physicists now say matter is less substantial than they thought. Convergence?
Practical Takeaways
-
You are pattern, not stuff. Your identity persists through complete material turnover. What matters is the pattern.
-
Stability is the goal. The universe maintains stable patterns (atoms, molecules, you). Stability, not substance, is what physical existence means.
-
Relationships matter more than things. This is true at the level of quarks and at the level of human society.
-
Mystery remains. Seven years at CERN taught the author how much we don’t know. The deeper you look, the stranger it gets.
For the Unscarcity Framework
This understanding of matter supports several framework principles:
-
Pattern identity: If you are a pattern, consciousness upload (transferring the pattern to new substrate) becomes conceptually coherent.
-
Substrate neutrality: If matter is field excitation, there’s no principled reason carbon-based patterns are more real than silicon-based ones.
-
Experience as sacred: If consciousness is the one irreducible thing, treating it as sacred makes physical as well as moral sense.
Related Articles
- The Sacred Question - Where physics and faith converge
- Quantum Observation Mystery - Why looking changes reality
- Simulation Science - Information-theoretic reality
- Consciousness Upload - Pattern transfer between substrates
- The Silicon Mind - Consciousness in different hardware
Further Reading
- Frank Wilczek, The Lightness of Being (2008)
- Sean Carroll, The Particle at the End of the Universe (2012)
- John Wheeler, “Information, Physics, Quantum” (1990)
- Werner Heisenberg, Physics and Philosophy (1958)
- The CERN website: home.cern
