The Fed Chair Asked Whether AI Is the China Shock for Office Jobs. His Staff Is Modeling a Boom Where Unemployment Rises Anyway, and the Same Fed Is Weighing a Rate Hike Next Month Because AI Spending Is Running Hot
About This Episode
Fed Chairman Kevin Warsh opened a Fed conference in San Francisco on Monday, November 16, by saying staff are gaming out three AI scenarios: a boom shared with workers, a boom in which automation pushes unemployment up anyway, and a bust in which AI disappoints and stocks fall. From the stage he asked whether AI could do to services what the China shock did to goods, cheaper prices at the cost of jobs, while his committee weighs a December rate hike because AI spending is heating up the economy. The Fed's one lever, the price of borrowing, does not obviously reach a worker displaced in a growing economy.
Our Take
The Fed chair said out loud that AI could do to office work what the China shock did to factory towns, cheaper services and fewer jobs, and his own scenarios include a boom where unemployment rises anyway; the episode asks what a central bank with one lever, the price of borrowing, can actually do for the person on the wrong side of that boom.
Continue Reading on Unscarcity
The Abundance J-Curve: Why Cheap Later Means Expensive Now
Direct match: the article is about this Fed, this chairman and this task force, and its frame (AI makes things dearer now and cheaper later, and the only fast-moving institution holds one blunt lever) is exactly the gap between Warsh's December rate-hike debate and his question about AI disinflation in services.
Human Reserved: Can You Fence Off Work From the Machines?
Andreessen's claim that regulation in healthcare and education has 'mostly outlawed' the job transition is a fence argument, and the article's point is that a fence only protects the jobs inside it, which leaves the legal and administrative work Warsh's China-shock comparison is about.